When a loved one is killed in a motor vehicle collision, one of the most painful discoveries a grieving family can make is that the negligent driver carried minimal personal auto insurance. Under Michigan law, drivers can carry bodily injury liability policies as low as $50,000 per person ($100,000 per crash) or the standard $250,000/$500,000 limits. In a Michigan auto wrongful death claim, those personal policy limits fall far short of covering a lifetime of lost household income, funeral costs, and the devastating loss of a spouse or parent.
However, if the at-fault driver was on the clock or running a work errand at the time of the crash – even while driving their own personal car – your family may have legal grounds to pursue compensation from the driver’s employer and their commercial insurance policy.
Why Personal Auto Policies Are Often Not Enough in Fatal Crashes
In Michigan, surviving family members rely on two separate legal tracks after a fatal crash:
- First-Party No-Fault Survivors’ Loss Benefits (MCL 500.3108): Paid by the applicable household auto insurer regardless of fault, covering up to three years of after-tax economic support (subject to the monthly statutory cap) and funeral expenses.
- Third-Party Wrongful Death Lawsuit (MCL 600.2922): Filed against the at-fault party to recover non-economic damages—such as loss of companionship, society, and pre-death conscious pain and suffering—plus long-term lost earnings beyond the three-year No-Fault limit.
Because third-party damages in a fatal crash often reach into the millions of dollars, identifying every responsible party and every available insurance policy is critical.
How Employer Liability (Respondeat Superior) Works in Michigan
Under a long-standing legal doctrine called respondeat superior (often referred to as vicarious liability), an employer is legally responsible for the negligent actions of an employee who is acting within the scope of their employment.
Crucially, the driver does not need to be driving a branded company truck or van for the employer to be liable. If an employee is driving their personal sedan, pickup truck, or SUV to perform a task that benefits their employer, the company’s commercial auto liability or general liability policy (often carrying $1 million or more in coverage) can be brought into the wrongful death claim.
Common Work Errands That Can Trigger Commercial Coverage
Michigan courts look closely at the purpose of the trip, whether it occurred during work hours, and whether it served the employer’s business interests. Examples of everyday work activities in a personal vehicle that frequently establish employer liability include:
-
Traveling Between Job Sites: A contractor, home health nurse, or technician driving from one client location to another.
-
Office Supply, Bank, or Post Office Runs: An administrative employee sent out by a manager to drop off mail, pick up lunch for a client meeting, or buy office supplies.
-
Off-Site Client Meetings or Conferences: Sales representatives, real estate agents, or consultants driving to meet clients or attend required business events.
-
App-Based & Local Deliveries: Drivers delivering food, parts, or packages on behalf of a business or dispatch platform.
The “Commuting Rule” vs. Special Work Errands
Insurance defense attorneys frequently argue that an employer is not responsible because the employee was merely driving to or from work. Under Michigan’s general “going and coming” rule, an ordinary daily commute between home and a fixed workplace is usually considered personal time.
However, important exceptions apply:
-
Special Missions or Errands: If a supervisor asked the employee to stop at a supply store or drop off equipment on their way home, the trip becomes a business errand.
-
Paid Travel Time or Mileage Reimbursement: If the employer was compensating the driver for travel time or mileage during the trip, courts are far more likely to find the driver was acting within the scope of employment.
-
No Fixed Workplace: Employees who travel directly from home to rotating customer sites as a core part of their job often fall outside the standard commuting exception.
Why Early Investigation Is Critical
At-fault drivers and their employers rarely volunteer that a crash happened during a work errand. In fact, a police crash report (UD-10) will typically list only the driver’s personal auto insurance card from their glovebox.
When our legal team investigates a fatal crash early, we look beyond the police report – issuing preservation notices and subpoenas for cell phone call logs, text messages, work dispatch records, GPS data, and mileage expense reports. Uncovering that a driver was running a work errand can completely change the financial recovery available to protect a grieving family’s future.
Speak With a Michigan Auto Wrongful Death Attorney
If your family lost a loved one in a fatal Michigan collision, do not assume the other driver’s personal insurance policy is the end of the road. At Bahrie Law, PLLC, our attorneys have spent more than 45 years investigating complex fatal crashes across Michigan to uncover every source of compensation.
Call us today at 888-473-1289 or contact us online to schedule a free, confidential consultation. You pay no upfront attorney fees unless we recover compensation for your family.
